The Decision a Court Will Make for You
If both parents die or become permanently incapacitated without naming a guardian, a Utah district court holds a guardianship proceeding. A judge — who has never met your children, doesn't know your values, and has no idea who your kids call every Sunday — decides who raises them.
Family members may petition the court for guardianship. That can mean your parents, your spouse's parents, a sibling, a cousin — anyone with a plausible connection can ask a judge for custody. When more than one family member petitions, the proceeding can turn into a dispute that lasts months, during which your children's living situation is unresolved.
The court's only standard is the best interest of the child. That is a broad standard, and it gives judges significant discretion. It does not mean the court will pick the person you would have chosen.
A common scenario. A young couple in their thirties is killed in a car accident. They have two children, ages four and seven. The husband's parents live in Utah and immediately petition for guardianship. The wife's sister — who was close to the children and whom the couple had always informally intended to raise them — lives in California and also petitions.
There is no will. There is no written guardian nomination. The court must weigh the claims of both sides, consider the children's ties to Utah, assess each petitioner's fitness, and ultimately choose — without any guidance from the only people whose opinion actually mattered.
A single document, signed before the accident, would have resolved this entirely.
How to Legally Name a Guardian in Utah
Under Utah Code § 75-5-202, a parent may nominate a guardian for a minor child in a will. That nomination is not automatically binding — a court must confirm the appointment — but Utah courts give very strong deference to a parent's written, signed nomination. In the absence of a compelling reason to disregard it, the court will appoint the person you named.
The nomination may appear in a validly executed will under Utah law. An informal letter, a text message, a note tucked in a drawer, or a conversation you had with your sister over dinner carries little to no legal weight. If it is not in a signed will, it may not exist as far as a court is concerned.
When both parents are alive, either parent may nominate a guardian. If your nominations conflict, the nomination of the parent who died later takes priority. That said, it is still better for spouses to agree on a guardian and name the same person in both wills — so that the surviving parent's choice is clear and deliberate, not simply the default result of dying second.
Talk to your chosen guardian before naming them. A guardian who is surprised by the nomination — or who would prefer not to serve — creates exactly the kind of uncertainty you are trying to avoid. Have the conversation first, confirm they are willing, and then put the name in writing.
The Godparent Myth
One of the most common misconceptions among young parents is that naming someone as a godparent gives them legal authority over a child. It does not.
A godparent is a social and religious designation. It carries deep personal meaning and is an important expression of trust and relationship. But under Utah law — and every other state's law — being a godparent confers no custody rights, no legal standing, and no authority to make decisions for a child. A godparent who is not named as guardian in a will has no more legal claim to your children than a stranger.
If the person you want raising your children is also your chosen godparent, that is wonderful. But the godparent designation does not substitute for the legal nomination. Both need to exist independently.
Why You Need a Backup Guardian
Your first choice of guardian may not be available when the time comes. They might predecease you. They might become seriously ill. They might decline the role when the moment arrives. Life circumstances — a divorce, a move across the country, a new disability — can change what is realistic for the person you had in mind.
A guardian nomination without a named alternate means that if your primary choice cannot or will not serve, the court proceeds without guidance — the same position as if you had named no one at all.
Name a primary guardian and at least one alternate. Some parents name two alternates. The goal is to give the court a clear line of succession that reflects your actual wishes, not a single name that becomes useless if circumstances change.
Choosing the Right Guardian: What to Consider
There is no universal answer to who should raise your children. The right person depends on your family, your values, and your children's specific needs. The following factors are worth working through carefully:
Shared values
Will this person raise your children with the same religious commitments, educational priorities, and general approach to life that matter to you? A guardian who shares your core values will make thousands of small decisions in the way you would have made them.
Relationship with the children
Does your child already know and trust this person? A guardian who is already a significant presence in a child's life provides continuity at the most disorienting time imaginable. A technically qualified guardian who is a near-stranger provides no such comfort.
Stability and capacity
Consider the guardian's age and health, the stability of their marriage or relationship, their financial situation, and where they live. A guardian who would need to uproot your children from their school, friends, and community adds another layer of loss to an already devastating situation.
Their own children
If your chosen guardian already has children, your children would become part of that household. Think about how many children that creates, how the ages interact, and whether the household could realistically absorb yours.
Willingness
The most important factor of all. A guardian who has agreed to serve, understands what that means, and genuinely wants the role is worth far more than the most qualified person on paper who has never been asked.
Ready to name a guardian for your children?
A will that names a guardian is one of the most important documents a young parent can have. A free consultation takes 30 minutes and gives you a clear picture of what your family needs.Separating the Guardian from the Trustee
A guardian is responsible for the child — where they live, what school they attend, their medical care, their daily life. A trustee is responsible for the money — managing the assets you leave behind and distributing them for the child's benefit.
These do not have to be the same person, and in many cases it is better if they are not.
The person best suited to raise your children may not be the person best suited to manage a trust. A sibling who would be a wonderful, loving guardian might have no experience with investments or financial management. A financially sophisticated friend might be an ideal trustee but have no relationship with your children. Splitting the roles lets each person do what they are actually equipped to do.
It also creates a natural check on how the money is used. A trustee who is separate from the guardian can evaluate requests for distributions objectively. A guardian who controls the money faces no such oversight.
A trust set up through your estate plan — rather than leaving assets outright to the guardian — is the cleaner way to accomplish this. Assets in a trust are managed by the trustee according to the terms you set, distributed for the child's health, education, and support, and preserved until the child reaches an age you specify.
Put Your Wishes in Writing
Beyond the legal nomination, consider writing a letter of intent — an informal document that explains your parenting philosophy, your hopes for your children, your preferences on religion and education, and anything else a guardian would benefit from knowing. This letter is not a legal document and is not binding, but it gives the person raising your children something they cannot get from a court order: a window into who you were as a parent and what you wanted for your kids.
Don't wait for the "right time." Young parents are statistically unlikely to die before their children grow up. But unlikely is not impossible, and the cost of being wrong without a plan in place falls entirely on the children. A will that names a guardian takes an afternoon to prepare. The consequences of not having one can last a child's entire life.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
No. Being a godparent is a social and religious designation with no legal meaning under Utah law. A godparent has no automatic right to custody, no authority to make decisions for your child, and no standing that a court is required to consider. If you want a specific person to raise your children, you must name them as guardian in your will.
-
Under Utah Code § 75-5-202, a parent may nominate a guardian for a minor child in a will. The nomination is not automatically binding — a court must confirm the appointment — but Utah courts give strong deference to a parent's written nomination. The will must be validly executed under Utah law to be effective.
-
A Utah district court will hold a guardianship proceeding and appoint whoever it determines is in the child's best interest. Family members — grandparents, aunts and uncles, siblings — may all petition for guardianship, and the court decides without any written guidance from the parents. The process can take months, during which the child's living situation may be uncertain.
-
Yes — and in many cases it is wise to do so. The guardian of the person is responsible for the day-to-day care and upbringing of the child. A separate trustee can manage the financial assets you leave behind. This separation prevents a situation where the person best suited to parent your children is also burdened with managing a trust, or where a financially savvy trustee is put in charge of raising children they have no relationship with.
-
It significantly reduces the likelihood of one. A court is not required to follow a guardian nomination, but Utah courts give it very strong weight. A written, signed nomination in a valid will is far more persuasive than any verbal statement you may have made, and it gives the court clear evidence of your intent. It does not make a contested proceeding impossible, but it makes the outcome far more predictable.